[ietf-dkim] ADSP stats

[Barry Leiba]

> Internationalized domain names MUST be converted as described in Section
> 2.3 of [RFC5890] to "A-Labels"
> '---
>
> This failed to specify Fake A-Labels should not be permitted.  The point
> made by Ticket #17.  RFC5980 introduces restrictions against 3,329
> confusable unicode points not excluded by RFC3490.  Unless A-label
> validity checks are made by DKIM, it is not reasonable to assume
> RFC5980's added protection are afforded

The consensus of the working group, and the guidance from the IESG,
was to allow RFC 5890 and its co-documents to specify the
internationalization aspects.  It is well out of scope for DKIM to try
to do it.  I have seen no support for expanding the statement beyond
what's covered by ticket #4.

I'm happy to re-open ticket #17, and leave it open until WGLC ends,
but unless there's clear support for it, it will then be closed again.

Barry, as chair