[ietf-dkim] DKIM+ADSP = FAIL, and it's our fault
jdfalk-lists at cybernothing.org
Tue Sep 14 12:35:09 PDT 2010
...but not for the reasons the anti-ADSP folks keep bringing up.
DKIM is failing because every discussion about actually /using/ DKIM inevitably gets stuck in the same old argument about ADSP. Doesn't even matter what the argument is about anymore; it stops all forward progress every time. And we keep letting it happen -- actively participating, even, including me.
Continuing to argue these same points over and over is disrespectful of our colleagues both on and off this list, and of the IETF process.
So I'm going to stop, and I beg you all to join me.
Stop arguing, and start writing drafts. Let us discuss the drafts instead of attacking each others' intractable positions for the Nth time. If you think ADSP will bring about the end of all human communication, WRITE A DRAFT EXPLAINING WHY. If you think something else, write that instead.
Yes, I know it requires more effort, but what we've been doing so far clearly isn't working.
More information about the ietf-dkim