[ietf-dkim] draft-ietf-dkim-mailinglists-02 review
John R. Levine
johnl at iecc.com
Fri Sep 10 12:34:40 PDT 2010
> The problem is that too many people on this WG take the view "I believe in
> solution-X (TPA, PGP-MIME, don't use ADSP because it's broke, don't use
> mailing list if you advertise 'discardable') and I will vote down any
> solution other than X".
Call me old-fashioned if you will, but I take the view that a purely
hypothetical paper design to address a largely hypothetical problem, with
unknown security problems, unknown user interface problems, and unknown
interoperation problems have no place in a document about actual e-mail
If this is a viable solution to an important problem, why haven't you
implemented it yet? There's no shortage of open source MLMs to adapt.
"Running code and rough consensus" requires running code, you know.
More information about the ietf-dkim