[ietf-dkim] Collection of use cases for SSP requirements

[Michael Thomas]

Steve Atkins wrote:
>
> On Nov 13, 2006, at 1:08 PM, Stephen Farrell wrote:
>
>>
>>
>> Steve Atkins wrote:
>>
>>> The three I see mentioned are
>>>   1. I sign all mail I send with DKIM.
>>>   2. Someone else is sending mail with my domain in RFC822 From:
>>>   3. I send no mail.
>>
>> No. The use cases the WG is working on are documented in the
>> ssp-reqs draft. I hope you've read that. If not, please do so
>> and the comment on that text.
>>
>> (Note that it doesn't matter whether your list above is right
>> or wrong. What matters is that there's already a list in the
>> ssp-reqs draft.)
>
> Well, I believe the list is wrong, however it isn't my list,
> it's the list in dkim-ssp-requirements-02.
>
>   4.1.  Problem Scenario 1: All Mail Signed with DKIM
>   4.2.  Problem Scenario 2: Illegitimate Domain Name Use
>   4.3.  Problem Scenario 3: Domain Sends No Mail
>
> Perhaps you could read the draft, and clarify if I've misunderstood
> something.
As the person who wrote 4.2, it definitely does not correspond to
your #2. I'm somewhat at a loss as to how you could have interpreted
it that way.

          Mike